The Engine Room: The History of Jazz Drumming is a fantastic 4 CD box set released by Proper Records that covers the eras “from Storyville to 52nd Street” and includes 95 tracks recorded between 1923 and 1948.
I’m always surprised when I meet a jazz drummer who doesn’t know about this set of discs, so I decided it’s time to write a quick post about it.
I first heard about this set during an interview with Kenny Washington on the Drummer’s Resource Podcast (a fantastic interview worth checking out). Kenny mentioned that Engine Room is out of print, so I got obsessed with finding a copy. Luckily, it’s still pretty easy to find, though the price of used copies can vary a bit. I’ve purchased a couple of copies off of Amazon and I’ve seen them range from $30 to $200, though I paid about $50 for each of my copies.
The booklet included with the set is around 50 pages and includes wonderful liner notes by Joop Visser. This alone makes it worth finding a physical copy.
The eras represented:
Disc 1: New Orleans & Chicago styles
Disc 2: Swing
Disc 3: Big Band
Disc 4: Modernism
It’s worth noting that there are two different versions of the packaging. The differences are trivial, but here’s a list if you’re curious:
- The earlier 1999 set was thicker overall due to the use of plastic jewel cases
- The latter 2005 release was thin and used cardboard sleeves
- The UPC code is the same on both sets
- The booklet is essentially the same in both sets, containing the same information and liner notes. One is a few pages longer than the other, but it’s just because there were added pages for record label promotion.
- The 2005 set is listed as digitally re-mastered, though I’m unable to hear a difference between the two sets.
Finally, here are some photos of the two sets:
5 thoughts on “The Engine Room: The History of Jazz Drumming”
Thanks so much for including the DR interview on here and linking to it.
Super cool of you!
Hi! there is a third one. it has jewel cases but with the pictures of the 2005 card sleeves in it. i own this one.
Interesting! I’d love to see a photo of it. Can you send one to email@example.com ?
Maybe you just turned the inlays of the 1999 jewel cases? Are there the pictures from the 2005 set around? If so it seems to be the same if not you get pictures from my box.
You are right! My inlays were turned around.